Showing posts with label Review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Review. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 2, 2013

Review : Bruno's Dream

In lieu of writing a sprawling review of Bruno’s Dream (as I am not wont to do) I would like to focus more specifically on the way in which I approached this novel; first by reading it to myself, by listening to it be read aloud to me and finally (as more of an afterthought) to reading the text aloud to another. In an age where the New York Times bestseller list is being overshadowed by Amazon Kindle’s Top Ten Audiobooks (and even worse, that Nicholas Sparks is topping both those charts, but that is completely beside the point) I’d like to use my experience with Bruno’s Dream to parse out why, when someone tells me they’ve “read” a book (and actually mean they’ve listened to it) I cannot believe that they’ve fully absorbed the material. I liken this to the dining experience – one would not say they’ve “cooked” dinner if they are going out to a restaurant, despite the fact that the meal could be roughly the same (we’ll assume “one” is a capable cook), there is a completely different experience to have the plate be brought before you and actively preparing the plate yourself. Similarly, reading to me is the act of reading, i.e. passing one’s eyes across printed words in an effort to obtain information. Although listening to the story read aloud achieves the same purpose, information consumption, there is something lost in the transmission -- the proximity to the written word, the construction of sentences, as an integral part of reading. Nevertheless, listening to a story aloud has an impressible power over the imagination to create scenes in the mind based on the action one is hearing (not to mention the fact that we owe a great deal to the ancient oral tradition in developing the storytelling design and practices we still use today – a tradition entirely worth preserving) For a writer like Murdoch, let me begin by saying, prose matters. When reading the first two thirds of her book to myself, there are countless choices she makes that I would not have noticed had I been listening to the text being read aloud. For instance, Murdoch places song lyrics intermittently throughout the beginning of the book, songs which evoke frivolity for some characters (“Our lodger’s such a nice young man, such a nice young man is he” 30) and nostalgia in others (“At the parting of the ways, You took all my happy days, And left me lonely nights” 15) These lines are italicized and provide a contrast to both the third and first person narrative styles, offering an internal reverie of the characters, a kind of drifting off as they’re reflecting in the past or simply going about their daily business. In fact, italics are heavily used by Murdoch in general and convey the stress she wishes the words to be placed particularly in dialogue scenes (e.g. “I can’t see why you’re so upset” or “To have lunch with him?”) This allows for the reader to construct the scene in their mind and, more importantly, the affect of these characters; we can tell that Miles is aghast and incredulous at Danby’s proposition of a lunch date with Lisa but not necessarily because of his resentments towards Danby (as one would assume, in that case, that the italics would be used for him instead of lunch) but because he has not regarded Lisa as a “lady who lunches” so to speak. Similarly, when Bruno corrects Danby’s use of the term “longing” when described to Miles, the word “you’re” is italicized rather than “why”, suggesting, not only that Danby should not be upset, but that Bruno himself is the one who has claim to that right. These italicized intricacies are found in abundance while reading this novel in particular and provide added identity and depth to each of the characters. The last third of the book was generously read aloud to me, most notably during the two major climaxes, the duel and the deluge. For me, these action scenes were the best sections in the novel to be read aloud, as I was able to construct the scenes in my mind and not be burdened with the words (or the temptation of glancing ahead “accidentally” to see what happens) These scenes, the force of which is derived from what the characters are doing rather than saying, retained their power as I listened to the story unfold. I cannot believe I lost any of the tension that resulted in Danby and Will stepping out at dawn to face each other, particularly when it was discovered that the pistols were indeed loaded. I did not need to maintain my composure to allow the novel to continue, I could flinch, groan, squeeze my eyes shut in anticipation and the story persisted thanks to my able bodied lector. Moreover, the frantic urgency of Adelaide, as she discovers that the flood has found her and Bruno alone in the house, is somewhat more palpable for me as I closed my eyes and imagined Bruno’s figure on the stairs screaming “Adelaide, the stamps, the stamps!” -- italics were not needed to effectively portray Bruno’s desperation, to say the least. Despite these benefits, I was obligated to go back and reread the conclusion, as there were complexities, particularly with Diana and Bruno’s resolution, which I missed originally when I was listening for a conclusion. Ultimately, I will always opt to read the book myself versus listening to it because I strive to be an active participant in the novel. In novels like Bruno’s Dream, every italicized line, every page break, even every comma, has the potential to convey something crucial about the characters and about the narrative proper. I do not wish to passively allow a reader to interpret the language of the text for me, even if that means I must restrain my winces and shudders of fear (okay, I did not really “shudder in fear” during the duel scene, but who knows? Perhaps Babbitt will have a vicious, violent sequence that would cause such a physical reaction) As a side note, I did have the opportunity to read two chapters of the text aloud to an audience. Although studies have shown that this allegedly reinforces the material comprehensively for long term memory, I found that I was too distracted by properly conveying the cadence and inflection of the text to my audience to successfully retain any of the information I was reciting in the moment. Perhaps my performance anxiety is more severe than most, but I would like to sincerely thank my reading partner for assuming the reins of this experiment and allowing me to sit back, relax and listen to the conclusion of Murdoch’s “sombre and lively meditation”

Saturday, September 28, 2013

Review: Bruno's Dream

Bruno’s Dream is a tricky novel to pin down. It seems at once classic and contemporary. Both tragic and comic.  A novel with a lofty vision and a pulpy melodrama. In some ways it was a traditional dramatic work: it exhibited well defined three-act structure with (several) distinct climaxes, as well as very strong unities of place and action. This latter feature gives the story something of a theatre set feeling – the action is effectively limited to a complex web of need between 7 characters, taking place in an obscurely sketched house on the Thames.  Each character’s emptiness (ranging from mild boredom to angst in the face of death) is foregrounded in turn, and, with Bruno’s dream of reuniting with his son, the web begins to spin. As such, and a-traditionally, there is no single protagonist. Moreover, while the purported climax of the book works itself out in almost clichédly symbolic situations – the duel and, all the more, the Deluge – and while these are followed by a stylistic and temporal break that is typically a cue that we are well into the ‘resolution’ or ‘falling action’ of the narrative, there is something altogether irresolved about this supposed denouement. And I think this is because the dual/deluge event is something of a red herring in making sense of the plot. It is hard to see how these events have any bearing on what follows them. Objectively, we can track all our characters: Miles and Diana find a cozy balance, Adelaide runs off with Will, Nigel declares his love for Danby and sets off on his next caper, and Lisa and Danby become involved.  Each character seems to have paired off in a way that makes sense. But are they better for it? Or are the events that transpire just another episode in their lives, still so full of the small love of self-love? And what, after all, about Bruno?
I want to suggest that for the most part, these characters are not dynamic characters – they do not exhibit substantial change as a result of undergoing the conflict. Or perhaps more accurate is to say that they make very small victories. I think what is at stake in Bruno’s dream is none other than what is at stake in Plato’s Symposium – the soul’s progress from “the lesser mysteries of love” to the vision of the true divine Love. And while most of the characters make some bit of progress down this path, I think only two of them, namely, Diana and Bruno, are left with a lasting (and Real) vision of Love. These visions take the form of epiphany; both Diana and Bruno ‘wake up’.
                Diana’s epiphany – her ascending from a less pure to a more pure vision of Love – happens while she is bedside with Bruno in his final days (Ch. 32). Diana’s love never strikes us as a selfish love – especially in contrast to characters like Danby, Adelaide, and Miles. She gets great fulfillment from caring – and yet a closer reading does indicate that she gets (and expects) something in return for her care:

“Making the house had taken years and within it she had occupied years in posing….She had never dreamed of so distinguished a catch. She would have been contented with much less…but could not help contemplate with satisfaction the gap between her mother’s life and her own…She played the passionate exacting mistress…she charmed herself”

Here we can see that Diana’s love serves to enforce her identity, her sense of her-self. It is subtle, like I said, especially in comparison to the other characters, but this passage makes clear that not only does she find playing the role of (or ‘posing’ as) mistress/savior “charming” but that her understanding of Miles “distinguished” status serves to distinguish her – in this case, from her mother. It is also clear that the way Diana differentiates herself, carves out a self-conception, is gives her ‘satisfaction’.
This separate sense of self is – at least according to the metaphysic espoused by the books native shaman, Nigel – precisely the root of the dreaming and delusion – the love that should be emanating forth is turned back into self-love, and is put into the service of love’s opposite – or reinforcing separateness and sense of Self.
It is precisely because Diana is only so subtly using love to define her Self that she is capable of being disabused of her delusions in the end. Compare how deeply lost in petty love Adelaide is, and how here glamorous future will only serve to aggravate this lostness.  And yet common sense tells us that things worked out for Adelaide while Diana perhaps lost the most of any character (even Bruno seems to gain from his death). After all, Diana ends nearly overcome by pain. Still, such pain is a sign of progress, in the same way the Cave Dweller’s initial exposure to the light of day is painful and dazzling. For in these final moments with Bruno, Diana, wonders “Perhaps this great pain was just her profitless love for Bruno” (310), and “Becoming so attached to someone who is dying. Is this not the most pointless of all loves?” (309). What is profit, what is point? They are the goals set by the separated self in light of its perceived needs. Diana has, more than any other character, overcome herself and her ‘natural’ conception of love as serving a need (contrast this with Lisa, who moves backwards, towards a conception of love that serves her, “sanely self interested” love.). We need only consider two things to see this: first, it is rather a shock to find, in the last chapter, that it is Diana who regularly visiting Bruno – the last we really saw was her rushing from the house in disgust (and, significantly, resorting to some harmless flirtation with a strange man). Something in her has loosened up, has opened up, and now here she is loving Bruno – the one holding his hand as he passes and so too confronting Profitless Love in the face of Death. And her resolve in the face of these disconcerting inhuman forces yields its own profitless vision (viz., of Love-as-all) and its own death (viz, of her self): “She tried to think about herself but there seemed to be nothing there…Yet love still existed and it was the only thing that existed” (310).  This, then, is Diana’s epiphany.
                In the final chapter, Bruno makes an identical movement from darkness to light. It is rather simpler and more straightforward. Bruno’s real illness is the mixture of his crippling doubt and his inveterately pessimistic way of filling in the gaps in his knowledge:

“Supposing Janie had wanted to forgive him at the end after all? He would never know. The most precious thing of all was lost to him forever” (40)

This passage - so telling of how a single unresolved emotion can develop into an ever intensifying, crippling obsession – has a dual reading. There is a gap between his “never knowing” and “the most precious thing”: That is, we do not know if “the most precious thing” to Bruno is Janie’s forgiveness, or the knowledge, the closure, of whether she ended forgiving or berating him. For, IF the “most precious thing” is simply that Janie dies forgiving me, he cannot know that this is lost forever. Indeed, he thinks: he would never know if she forgave him. So what Bruno wants (and fears lost) is not that Janie forgave him, but the knowledge that she forgave him –THIS is what, he believes, is lost forever. So here too, on page 40, Bruno is not concerned with how-Janie-felt-when-she-died-as-such, but rather with Janie qua the Other who serves to validate/exonerate his own guilt. Bruno, like Diana, indeed like all the other characters, is too struggling with the “lesser mysteries” of love – or, to use Gibran’s words, Bruno still, right up to his final moments, seeks only love’s peace and love’s pleasures.
                But, like Diana, the Truth has a way of revealing itself rather unannounced. At the end, Bruno comes to see the rather simple fact that “it’s so obvious now that nothing else matters” other than “to be kind and good”. Bruno will never live a good life – he will never be a Good man; he knows rightly that nothing he can do know will change the fact the he loved so little, and loved so poorly. But it is the intense pain or this regret that points towards his failure and at once points to how things Ought to be:  “only in the presence of death… one could see so clearly what love ought to be like”. In the end, nothing matters except love (keeping Plato’s Symposium always in the back of our minds) and it is our own sense of our falling short of love that reveals the Ideal heights of Love, or, to be more explicitly Platonic, the Idea of Love. For him, like Diana, it is the presence of death which effectively puts an end on the sprawling human points and purposes and leaves us only to become receptive to our waywardness and, consequently, the One True Way. And he too (like Diana) out of the great, dismal swamp of his uncertainties, comes to have Absolute Knowledge, namely, “…the knowledge he had now, this absolute nothing-else-matters.”
There is a final consolation for Bruno – it is a sort of implication of his epiphany: for if Love is revealed concurrently with the death of the self, with the loss of all individually distinguishing features, then Bruno can know that his final episode is every one’s final episode – a disintegrating of the self back into the “All is one” (29) – a painful agonizing torturing of the “extended” back into “a single point” - the shedding of the delusion of the self and it’s lesser loves is the certain attainment of the Idea of Love: that this Love is all that there is; and as such, Bruno gets, at last, something like exoneration from Janie – for this absolute certainty is also a “presence” that all will experience as they disappear, and so Janie too would know that there is Love and nothing-else-matters: “Had Janie known this at the end? For the first time Bruno saw it with absolute certainty” This final epiphany at once which means that Janie forgives Bruno and that Bruno becomes certain of this fact, it means that in the end Bruno obtains his most precious thing. But really, what can it matter now, in the Presence of this absolute certainty?

***
Virtue has been compared to a bullseye – there are a million ways of missing it, but only one way of hitting it (if you’ve never thought about it before, now you can understand the cumbersome opening of Anna Karenina – “All happy families are alike; each unhappy family is unhappy in its own way”).  So the characters in Bruno’s Dream all fall short of love – which is just to say they are all, in their own way, less than virtuous in how they relate themselves to the world, to other people, and to themselves. And within this concentric, spinning universe, at least two of these characters (through what is more like an act of grace than an outcome of the plot or of personal effort) come to inhabit the sacred and singular center: to the hub of the wheel, which is motionless and empty while the wheel itself spins on; Or: they come to occupy the center of the web; and while they are not really liberated (for in the end there is no ‘they’ from which to be liberated) from here they can see, at last, how everything is connected. 

I liked this book. I found it compelling and intriguing but more importantly thought provoking and emotionally moving enough for me to be okay with the incestuous melodrama that actually made up it's plot. More importantly, the book for me possessed a strong philosophical argument about the Reality of the Good - and how we suffer needlessly when we are cut off from this source of light. Human destiny is a ethical destiny, and this is something that I too often forget, and of which I cannot too often be reminded. 


 
Dharmacakra (Buddhist Wheel) , Sun Temple, Orissa

Tuesday, September 10, 2013

Review


I have no idea what to expect. That was the prevailing sentiment I had prior to picking up Midnight’s Children and, surprisingly, it lasted up until the very last page. I chose to read this novel because it was unlike the standard tomes staring back at me from my bookshelf. I was ready for a new perspective and the subject matter, India’s independence, was unfamiliar territory. I hoped to catch a glimpse of a culture that has always seemed glaringly foreign to my scope of experience. Even the title, Midnight’s Children, had a romantic allure that seemed full of poetical promise of a new generation, meditative musings, possibly a twilight sequence. This is going to be great, I told myself, I have no idea what to expect.

            The opening sequence with Aadem Sinai in the Kashmir Valley and the introduction of the perforated sheet was sublime. It was undoubtedly the highlight of the novel for me. Kashmir felt like such a mythical, almost holy, place and the characters I encountered, Aadem, Tai, Ghani and his daughter, were fascinating individuals brimming with back-stories and future journeys that I was bracing myself to read. Unfortunately, this was the back-story and I, as the reader, would not stay in Kashmir for long. But because of the beauty and tranquility of that initial sequence, I maintained hope that the characters would at some point return to that serene valley. In the meantime, however, I was entreated to a narrative that became increasingly haphazard as the novel went on.

            The concept of the novel, we’re reading a story about a man writing a story and therefore we are reading that story as well, has the potential to provide an interesting perspective in comparison to your standard, run of the mill, omniscient narrator novels or even the first person, stream of consciousness narration. Yet in the case of Saleem Sinai, this mode is downright frustrating. If there were a competition in beating around the bush, Saleem would have the competition beat (please forgive the pun) The way in which he insists on the importance of an event over and over (e.g. the incident in the washing chest, Shiva, the Widow, etc) and still fails to describe the event had me ready to hurl his story across the room or, taking a queue from Padma, just walk away. Why didn’t I? Well for a large portion of the novel there was a promise of “magical realism” lingering in the back of my mind, more specifically, I was hoping that the grandeur of the titular children, the MCC, would come to a head and dazzle me the way I wanted to be, and after reading chapter upon chapter of Saleem’s rants, deserved to be dazzled. Here again, I had no idea that this promise would remain unfulfilled and that the MCC would “end before it even began” as one member prophesized.

            Perhaps Saleem’s rants would not have seemed so arduous had it not been for the bevy of characters presented who were so thoroughly cloying and so far from redeemable that I cared very little for their fates. That is not to say that I didn’t give them a chance – I wanted to believe that Amina would remain faithful, or that Ahmed would sober up and finally rewrite the Quaran, or even that Saleem would grow up and maturely utilize the gift he had been given (in this case, I was telling myself that the ramblings of his narration were simply brought on by the spectre of death looming) Nevertheless these characters seemed to shirk every possible chance they had to redeem themselves to the point where, when the house caved in or when they were about to fall into six million pieces, I simply shrugged and said “good riddance”. (the one exception here would be Aadem’s revelation that he had “found God” and subsequent flight into certain death –I was not ready to let him go and his seeming descent into madness was hard to read)

            One appreciable fact of the novel for me was the correlation of Indian history with the fictitious lives of the characters. I learned about a fair number of historical events which occurred in India in the 20th century thanks to either their description in the novel or their reference to which I went and read with interest. Although it helps that I knew next to nothing about this time period and someone who isn’t a complete neophyte to this period would probably be familiar with these facts, I was happy to learn about them in this context.

            So, is this a “good” book? I am told that it is but you’d be hard pressed to find me in that chorus. I do not have a taste for magical realism (or postcolonial literature), even when used in such a disappointingly clever way. And although I am still intrigued by the faraway enchantment of Indian culture I think I’ll leave my pickled chutney in the cabinet for the winter because although I have no idea what to expect, at this point, I just do not care.

Sunday, September 1, 2013

Midnight's Children: Review

How to describe this book before passing judgment on it? The more neutral terms baroque, grotesque, extravagant, frenetic, and sprawling come to mind. So do the less neutral terms, unfocused, clamorous, unrestrained, repellent and disappointing. I don't know whether melodramtic is neutral or not, but it applies.The story no doubt had it's virtues - it never felt laboriously drawn out, or tedious (with the exception of that whole metaphorical/literal-passive/active nonsense); the action seem to proceed for the most part flowingly, haltlessly, in a fecundity of invention. And yet the very inventiveness of the book was in a large way fouled by what I consider the biggest drawback of the story: the grating, self-aggrandizing, and charmless voice of the narrator, Saleem. Not only was his constant analysis of his own narrative themes patronizing to the more advanced reader as well as indicating the mass appeal and intended audience of the book, but it served only to demystify the book - to flatten it out. As if this retrospective meta-story were not deflating enough, it is coupled with an equally repetitive and eventually eye-roll inducing foreshadowing technique. In the end, Saleem comes across as a failed man, a neurotic desperate to tell his story, but whose grating tone (imagine the emphatic and overly expressive tones of a mother telling her children a story; or a magician: now you see it....(gasp!!) now you don't!) refuses to let the story unfold with any kind of unity. His heavy hand turns the first page of each chapter, and is waiting at the end of each to interpret the very symbolism with which he (with that same heavy hand) told his story in the first place. And there would be more...that hand would become like a fist...and smash us square in the face more than once...but that story will have to wait (oh there is so much to tell and so little time! Nose! And Knees! Knees! And Nose! THE WIDOW FOR CHRISSAKES!).

Midnight's children is not so much about characters as it is about the elemental, earthen forces that permeate and ultimately erode the boundaries that our common sense metaphysic tries to maintain. It inelegantly grapples with the notions of personal identity through time, of history, nationalism and postcolonialism, family, intersubjectivity, and perhaps as much as anything else, with connectedness - the way things surpass, or fail to surpass, their boundaries. (Indeed, all the above themes involve questionable boundaries; but then again, all concepts just are boundaries.) People leek into each other. People move from dreams to reality (D'Costa) and from reality to dreams (Nadir). The boundaries blur, between fact and fiction. And of course, this is Saleems's own gift - creating a connection between things that are supposed to be most private and cloistered - the inner monologues of others. At stake is none other than our ability to make (limited) sense of our (limited) experiences. Literarily, this takes not only the form of discovering past facts, but of finding symbolic significance, and of seeing the fatedness of history. This very activity is as central to the book as what actually happened in the past, and this accounts for, on the one hand, the heavy handed presence of grieving old Saleem, and on the other, of the almost complete absence in the of truly moving, memorable interactions and events. For a novel, this story has virtually no dialogue - which is the narrator directly quoting the speech of characters. Instead, there is indirect discourse, the narrator paraphrasing, or more commonly, simply a quick description of what-things-were-like-at-that-time. The narrator is ambitious in the amount of time he wants to cover (three generations), so the reader often finds themselves in a period of time (when Nadir was living in the basement) months reduced to paragraphs, a narrative set in the imperfect tense, which lacks the small details and nuance that lend a story its verisimilitude along with its ability to connect with us and move us.
But verisimilitude is obviously not the rubric under which Rushdie operates. So far away from the texture of brute facticity, the story itself is dangerously supposed to be subsumed under the allegory of the post-colonial growing pains of India. Rushdie is compelled to unfold the action in a way that mirrors the history of his India, and given his rather unflattering perspective on that history, the story ends up being a melodramatic bemoaning, from which we quickly revoke our suspension of disbelief and our sympathies and empathies. Name a character that isn't hopelessly selfish. Name an event that doesn't end in disaster.
So what is the final effect of the book, beyond our personal preferences being satisfied/dissatisfied? I think contained in the book is a stoic vision about being an individual. Individuality - the simple concept of a boundary that separates an inner - "me" - from an outer "not-me" -- is not something that exists as such - it is a regulative an ideal (and perhaps a corrupt one), one that, on the personal level, is taking place in a person's self-defining choices, one that, on the geo-political level, is guiding the causes of war. Individualization - on what ever level - is a painful, never finished process. We try, often violently, to maintain the boundaries that we believe to be most real. Saleem's own attempt to make sense of himself, to give his life the unity of Purpose, ends in renunciation. For his final prophecy is more a fantasy than prediction - more under the sway of Thanatos then Apollo. Wouldn't it be nice, befitting of an ending, to yield to all the familiar old forces of dis-integration? As he points out, at the end, isn't the original lie, told to us in the cradle, Anything you want to be you can be? There are two ways to read the negation of this statement, viz., You cannot be anything you want. The first is that there are things that you want to be that you cannot be. The second, is that, of all the things you want to be, you cannot be any of them. And this is because "you" really cannot be any single "thing" at all.

Would I reread it? No. Would I recommend it? No. My excerpt on the cover: "Midnight's Children fails to engage readers either stylistically or emotionally. I will take away very little from this experience"